top of page

Overshoot: cognitive obsolescence and the population conundrum

Updated: May 15, 2023

Professor Bill Rees' recent thinking on the ways in which our mindsets aren't up to the task of navigating this crossroads of civilization makes for thought-provoking reading. His full comment was just published in February 2023 in the Journal of Population and Sustainability here. We're just reprinting the abstract....


The human enterprise is in overshoot; we exceed the long-term carrying capacity of Earth and are degrading the biophysical basis of our own existence. Despite decades of cumulative evidence, the world community has failed dismally in efforts to address this problem. I argue that cultural evolution and global change have outpaced bio-evolution; despite millennia of evolutionary history, the human brain and associated cognitive processes are functionally obsolete to deal with the human eco-crisis.

H. sapiens tends to respond to problems in simplistic, reductionist, mechanical ways. Simplistic diagnoses lead to simplistic remedies. Politically acceptable technical ‘solutions’ to global warming assume fossil fuels are the problem, require major capital investment and are promoted on the basis of profit potential, thousands of well-paying jobs and bland assurances that climate change can readily be rectified. If successful, this would merely extend overshoot. Complexity demands a systemic approach; to address overshoot requires unprecedented international cooperation in the design of coordinated policies to ensure a socially-just economic contraction, mostly in high-income countries, and significant population reductions everywhere.

The ultimate goal should be a human population in the vicinity of two billion thriving more equitably in ‘steady-state’ within the biophysical means of nature.

Keywords: carrying capacity; cognitive obsolescence; systems complexity; economic contraction; population planning.

68 views1 comment

1 Comment

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
Pam Pence
Pam Pence
Jul 30, 2023
Rated 5 out of 5 stars.

Clear, supported, thoughtful recap of humanity's dire conundrum. "May the odds be every in your favor"..."They are never in our favor!" per the Hunger Games. The answer is not mainly technology--the type of thinking that led us into this mess. Maybe, even with the horrors that are already baked into our future, this predicament we find ourselves in is the catalyst to propel us into the more mature, wise way of being...Homo sapient 2.0, that will allow some of us (I'll be dead by then) to pull ourselves together with heart, body and mind intelligence. Let's hope, and work toward that. It is better than the alternative.

bottom of page